« Position Statement on Medical MarijuanaA New Addiction Science Network Resource -- Welcome to the "Blog!" »

Drug Addiction as a "Disease"

02/11/09 | by the professor [mail] | Categories: General, Nomenclature

Does considering drug addiction as a "disease" help or hinder a better understanding about the nature, cause, and treatment of this 'disorder?'

Please see the Comments from "The Professor" for the ASNet perspective on considering "Addiction" as a disease.

[adsense:]

41 comments

Comment from: Joe Marini [Visitor]
I don't think that there is all that much difference between disease, condition, syndrome or disorder they all are something you can aquire or are born with, can be altered with medication or behavior modification therapy. Even the aquisition of an addiction is comparable to the contration of a disease.

You know that performing mouth-to-mouth resuscitation you might contract an bacterial or viral organisim that could cause you to have a "Disease, Disorder or syndrome" curable or incurable.

You also know that trying cocaine once could cause you to contract an addiction to the substance or it might not.

The major difference I think is the statistics of aqusition or Addiction Liability, the words are ambiguous they all cause changes in the body when present.
02/11/09 @ 12:09
Comment from: Tom Varco [Visitor] Email
Wikipedia gives an interesting model of differentiation between disease, disorder, and illness:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disease

In talking to people who know addicts, it seems that they generally blame the addict for being one. Calling it a disease might foster a different attitude towards addicts. Since "disease" is often a medical term, it might get the medical field more involved in addiction.

However, calling it a disease might have a negative effect... causing addiction to get lumped into the "pill-for-everything" criticisms.

If we decide to call addiction a disease, is there a specific point along the drug use continuum that it becomes one?
02/11/09 @ 12:58
Comment from: the professor [Member] Email
Some continuing thoughts on the use of the term "disease" to describe and classify drug addiction should help clarify why I think this is an important topic. And I go on record admitting that I have ignored this issue previously, thinking it wasn't really important; there are a lot of 'side shows' in the study of drug addiction that distract from the important issues. Often a lot of time and energy is wasted discussing issues that aren't really important, frequently involving seemingly trivial points that some make careers out of pursuing. The question of whether drug addiction represented a "disease, disorder, condition, syndrome" or whatever never really caught my interest before I was working recently on a seemingly unrelated project. Indeed, it seems important enough now to discuss it within the context of the Advanced Topics seminar, even though it should be a "Chapter 1" or "Chapter 2" topic in the previous course (i.e., PSY451 Drug Addiction).

Before doing the appropriate scholarly work (e.g., 'looking the term up,' consulting textbooks and review articles) and learning what I "should" think the term implies, I am curious about what implications it carries before thoroughly examining this issue academically and studying what other "addiction specialists" have to say about it.

First, "disease" usually implies "medical" and that's both good and bad. It's good because it suggests some organic/biological basis and not just the situation where one is misbehaving. It's bad because it implies the 'cure' is in medical treatment (aka the proverbial "magic pill") and even worse within the domain of the mainstream medical establishment (e.g., medical school, general hospitals and medical clinics). I find the last implication the most disturbing of all and of serious enough merit to consider avoiding the use of the term "disease." But of course there is more.

Second, the term "disease" seems to connote a disorder that is progressive if not checked by proper therapeutic intervention (and sometimes progressive even then because no effective treatments are available). Addiction and even the LATE stages of drug use leading up to addiction have this characteristic.

Third, "disease" implies a systemic disorder--the situation where an entire 'system' is affected and not just some isolated tissue like a simple infection. Addiction involves changes in brain reward and motivation systems and thus fulfills this characteristic as well.

The main downside of labeling drug addiction a "disease" is that it may be surrendering 'our' disorder (i.e., one clearly within the domain of motivational psychologists, behavioral neuroscientists, and psychopharmacologists) over to the "medical doctors" and at the same time disempowering the addict. (Interesting how well these two thoughts seems to fit into the same sentence, even 'stick' together, i.e., considering something within the domain of "medical doctors" while telling the patient they are helpless to remedy their own situation without a "real doctor's" guidance and help.) This attribute I certainly object to most strongly, and this single reservation may be enough to cause me to limit my labeling to that of a "disorder" and not a "disease."

The upside of considering drug addiction a "disease" includes:

1. biologically based, not within the normal control of the individual,

2. progressive, usually deteriorating condition that seldom spontaneously remits without appropriate intervention (often with a well-defined typical course), and

3. systemic disorder (i.e., involving an entire system, not just isolated tissue)--some integrative biological 'function' is seriously disrupted or threatened by the abnormal condition.

And there's the "1,2,3's" of why drug addiction should be considered a "disease." More thoughts are floating around in my brain that haven't yet crystallized enough to make it through to my finger tips (not even reaching the motor cortex yet), so that's enough for now. I'm more interested at present in learning what others think about this topic, particularly in light of my comments above.

(FYI: The issue that recently brought this to ‘center stage’ for me was my attempt to review several addiction treatment facilities that I thought were doing a reputable job of trying to treat drug addiction but which I soon discovered when delving into their treatment methods and ‘philosophies’ were in actuality pedaling psychodynamic BS:(, e.g., “we will help you discover the deep-seated psychological disturbances that led to your drug addiction and therefore maintain [non sequitur] your addiction.” Yuk! It briefly made me want to go back and complete medical school simply to dissociate myself from this type of thinking too often associated with “psychologists.” Labeling drug addiction as a “disease” [at least for me] quickly put some distance between my orientation and these charlatans. But then, I could be just trading one witch doctor for another!)
02/12/09 @ 00:09
Comment from: the professor [Member] Email
Replies specifically to the points raised by Joe and Tom.

First to Joe: I agreed with you most emphatically in the past. I'm now considering whether there IS something to be gained by labeling addiction as a "disease." Certainly these terms are ambiguous; no one really owns the territory to give definitive definitions beyond that found in a dictionary. And it's the connotations not the denotations that we’re addressing here. We have the opportunity to refine our use of the term and perhaps to put useful meaning back into it much like the term "addiction" when properly defined become useful again (see "Chapter 2" discussion about the use of the term "addiction).

Now onto Tom [pun intended ;)]: Yes, the first thing I'll do is "look it up in my Wikipedia" (hum, I’m quoting myself here) and then consult the numerous textbooks and journal articles in my office and later the library when this initial discussion has run its course. But I wanted to contemplate what I thought first, before being "educated" by the "experts." I wanted to get a feeling for what the term conveys before being given by other authors a specific use of the term beyond its literal meaning--thus, my solicitation of opinions and thoughts here and in class.

When does an addiction become a disease? That's almost rhetorical--obviously when it IS an addiction. But when does one consider the progression along the drug-use continuum to be a disease leading addiction? (noting the analogy raised by Joe) That's a tougher question. My quick answer is when the biological processes take over from the psychosocial processes that are critically important only during the earlier stages of drug use but which are not the actual cause of addiction. However, because there is no clear demarcation but rather a gradual transition that varies across individuals, a more specific answer becomes very tough.
02/12/09 @ 07:06
Comment from: AGP [Visitor] Email · http://www.rehabinfo.net
Hi Professor,

First of all, congratulations on the new blog! You've got so much to offer the community that a platform for discussion/dialogue is fantastic. Well done.

The contention against calling addiction a disease (implying - falsely at present - that a cure is available) is extremely problematic. Further, it allows con-artists to sell snake oil "cures" to the ignorant and desperate (often for obscene amounts of money). I'm ashamed to admit that I actually worked and supported one of these "charlatans" (as you accurately describe). The practice is unfortunately very alive, well and unregulated.

That said however, the disempowerment of an addict/alcoholic against their disease/disorder is a fundamental step towards recovery. Whether called "disease", "incurable" or otherwise, the addiction is something to which one must surrender in order to recover. Whether this benefits charlatans or doctors is secondary to the ultimate benefit of the person suffering, IMO.

"Disorder" on the other hand, does not offer the same degree of disempowerment. If one has a disorder (perhaps called "mild", or "slight"), one might suggest it could be easily overcome or simply tolerated. We know that addiction is far too destructive to foster any such mindset. For this reason, "disorder" might also have a similar drawback as a defining term as applied previously to "disease".

If one is suffering from an addiction, my hope is that the person is so completely and utterly defeated that he/she surrenders. Admitting that one suffers from a disease can be comforting and sufficiently daunting to make surrender a rational choice.

Disorder just doesn't cut it. Of course, I might be overly biased or not yet sufficiently informed about "disorder". Just my $0.02. :)




03/16/09 @ 20:22
Comment from: john panos [Member] Email
Hello Professor,
I was in the process of preparing a much longer response to this question including commentary on a recent article by Dagher & Robbins (2009). I must now forgo that response after viewing a recent webinar on translational neuroscience. The behavioral endpoint is now being viewed as a robust biomarker. As science progresses, the scientific community will begin to view more disorders as disease states. The evolution of the scientific view of addiction will shape the funding sources for research and treatment. The view of addiction as a disease or disorder will be a matter of selection by consequence.

John
05/12/09 @ 12:59
Comment from: ars72788 [Member] Email
I agree with what Tom said. Saying that addiction is a disease makes it more medically relavent to certain fields, and almost takes blame away from the addict for being an addict. Although, a disease isn't something that you would give yourself with any intent, and although I am not saying that an addict becomes an addict by choice, I do beleive there is some choice involved.
05/20/09 @ 17:07
Comment from: Drug Addiction [Visitor] · http://www.addiction-treatments.com/
If you are suffering from a drug addiction, there are drug addiction treatments that can help you now. Drug treatments are multi phased with both short and long term procedures. Drug addiction treatments needs best addiction treatment centers guidance to come out of the addictions. There are lots of treatment centers available in U.S.A and offering drug treatments, drug addicts live drug free life after taking the drug addiction treatments from treatment centers. Addiction treatment centers can provide a variety of services for those that need help conquering their drug addiction.

http://www.addiction-treatments.com/
07/01/09 @ 02:44
Comment from: matt reidhead [Visitor]
I would just like to clarify that drug addiction is not arguably a disease, it is a disease. It is easy for an outsider to look in on drug addiction as a choice, which it is at first, but so is overeating which causes multiple diseases. It is a an inner disease, a disease of the mind. Not something you can cure with drugs or treatments. the only person that can cure it is the pacient. This is the only disease of its kind, where it is souly up to the pacient to cure themselves. please understand that i am a drug addict and always will be due to my disease. although i have been clean for two years this deamon never goes away.
10/23/09 @ 12:46
Comment from: GoodTimes [Visitor] · http://www.family-drug-intervention.net/
Nothing like just trying to kick someone when they are down by now saying that they have a disease. Altho an addiction could be considered a disease, its not like we just contracted a disease, it is something that is now trying to be proved that something in our genes may make us more prone to certain types of drugs. If anything, a great love shown by an intervention could open up one's eye's to an addiction they have. Narconon Vista Bay has some great information on how we can go about an intervention and the steps we can take afterwards. If we cant help ourselves, lets get help from a place or person who has a proven track record. Keep up the good fight, we will win :) Much love to all!
11/03/09 @ 05:49
Comment from: Advantages of Online Learning [Visitor] · http://www.educationconnection.com/advantages/
Thanks for posting such useful items. I’ve been reading his blog with much interest. He’s certainly raised my awareness. This post is Well Organized and Informative.
12/10/09 @ 05:00
Comment from: Term Paper [Visitor] · http://www.flashpapers.com
Thanks for sharing this information and hope to read more from you.
12/11/09 @ 02:15
Comment from: Online bachelor degree [Visitor] Email · http://online-bachelor-degree.nebuck.com/
Hello friends,
Great post, very well written.
You should blog more about this.
I’ll definitely be subscribing.
Have a good day..
12/11/09 @ 15:10
Great post! I want to know when you update your blog, where can i subscribe to your blog.
12/15/09 @ 00:54
I liked your blog; just wanted to put out another free resource to help make your online ventures grow!
12/28/09 @ 01:56
Comment from: david [Visitor] · http://drugrehab-drugrehab.com
The Role of Drug Treatment and Drug Treatment Center
What is the role of
drug treatment and a drug treatment center? To answer the first question we need to understand what drug treatment is. Drug treatment is not treating symptoms of drug addiction with other drugs. Simply stated, drug treatment begins by taking a comprehensive look at an addict. We look at both the physical and psychological reasons why a person abuses alcohol or drugs. We look at the history of abuse, as well as the history of a person’s rehab experiences, if any. We look at the family and social dynamics of the addict. We certainly also evaluate the addicts health history. Based on this comprehensive review a qualified drug treatment counselor can then develop a treatment program that addresses the individual needs of the client.

Once this evaluation is complete, the actual programs of a drug treatment center takes over. Typically, a drug treatment center will have their patients for a minimum of 30 days. For many, this minimum stay may not be enough to really help the addict get to the root of their addiction. The professional drug treatment counselor will know and be able to evaluate the length of stay necessary to get the addict on a solid road of recovery. Once a program has been successfully completed in a drug treatment center, the resident will leave with a plan to continue the recovery process. This usually entails having a sponsor, and continuing with a personalized aftercare program. It should be noted that even after a person completes their stay at a quality drug treatment center, they must continue to work their program to have a hope at long-term recovery.

for more info http://www.drugrehabilitationnetwork.com
01/18/10 @ 08:31
How Alcohol Rehab Works
Alcohol rehab works by eradicating the physical and psychological roots of alcoholism itself. Again, alcohol addiction is a disease. Like all diseases, it has tangible causes, and only by eradicating those causes can alcohol rehabs expect to help patients get better. It’s important to note here that alcoholics are sick in body as well as in mind. Alcohol abuse treatment has to help them get better on both fronts. There are no partial victories in the fight against alcoholism. Alcohol rehab can only be successful if it helps you get completely better. And, again, there is no substitute for quality in the alcohol abuse treatment process. The right luxury rehab center can make a world of difference, first and foremost by ensuring that you get the most advanced care from the most competent caregivers. That principle is the bedrock of everything we do, and everything we are. Our rehab experts are all leading figures in the respective fields. More importantly, they genuinely care about their work, and about their patients. Alcohol rehab can only be successful if it’s conducted in a spirit of love and support. Don’t wait another day to finally start feeling the warmth.
01/19/10 @ 01:33
Comment from: magnetic energy generator [Visitor] · http://www.buildmagneticgenerator.com
Wow, thanks for the insightful post. I look forward to reading more from you.
My cousing was looking for this last night. Glad I found your article :- )
01/19/10 @ 20:05
Comment from: Addiction Treatment [Visitor] · http://www.addictions-treatments.com/
That was an insightful question. I would say drug addiction is a disorder rather athan a disease, because disease can be caught but disorder can only be developed. Addiction is a disorder that is developed to be dangerous like a disease by the addicts. Keep posting more like this.
01/21/10 @ 01:52
Comment from: Addiction Treatment [Visitor] · http://www.addictions-treatments.com/
That was an insightful question. I would say drug addiction is a disorder rather athan a disease, because disease can be caught but disorder can only be developed. Addiction is a disorder that is developed to be dangerous like a disease by the addicts.
01/21/10 @ 01:53
Comment from: david [Visitor] · http://drugrehab-drugrehab.com/
I agree drug addiction is a disease and drug addicts should be treated as patients and not as outcasts in society.
To get treated they should join a rehab center
01/21/10 @ 02:15
It honestly is one of the hardest things in the world for an addict to admit that they need drug treatment. Many will ignore it till the day they die in order not to feel the shame that they believe being revealed as a drug addict will bring them. First off, having a drug problem is not anything to be ashamed of. A vast majority of people all over the world are in desperate need of drug treatment, so you should banish that thought from your head.
01/21/10 @ 06:07
Comment from: yin yoga [Visitor] · http://www.yin-yoga.net
informative post to read!!!
01/26/10 @ 09:58
Drug treatment is not treating symptoms of drug addiction with other drugs. Simply stated, drug treatment begins by taking a comprehensive look at an addict. We look at both the physical and psychological reasons why a person abuses alcohol or drugs. We look at the history of abuse, as well as the history of a person’s rehab experiences, if any. We look at the family and social dynamics of the addict.
02/01/10 @ 05:58
Comment from: Harriett - nightlife cagayan de oro [Visitor] · http://spookscdo.com/
It's a disease, I totally agree.. Many factors are involve in it and practically those are the reasons why it can't be stop that simple.
02/12/10 @ 05:57
Comment from: Olivian [Visitor] · http://www.drugsrehabs.com/
Drug Rehabilitation Does Help
After admitting that you have an addiction, you still may need assurance that drug rehabilitation does help. With out seeking the professional help that drug rehabilitation centers offer, you are more at risk to fall into old habits and start abusing drugs again. This is a fact because, for one thing, you have not been given the support and tools needed to overcome your addiction, and two, you may not understand your addiction. Drug rehabilitation helps because you are under the care of a medically trained staff that is specifically trained to help you, and other addicts, recover.

If you are still unsure if you need drug rehabilitation, consider this. When you are trying to overcome your addiction, you are at your weakest, physically and mentally. You will be going through withdrawal and will be trying to overcome your mental cravings. If you are at home, the place where you can easily access your drug of choice, how can you hope to overcome your addiction in your weakest moments with temptation right in front of you? This is how drug rehabilitation helps, because it removes you from the temptation of drugs and then places you in a safe environment, where your privacy is protected.
02/23/10 @ 00:58
Comment from: Therapy4help [Visitor] · http://Therapy4help.com.
The therapist exerts varying strokes of strong pressure so as to relax the pressure points, which are also known as knots.
02/23/10 @ 04:21
Comment from: leland michaels [Visitor] · http://www.cocaineabuse.net/
yeah.It's a disease and a curse too. many factors affect the situation and I dont know how and when those will be removed
02/23/10 @ 12:12
Comment from: Therapy4help [Visitor] · http://Therapy4help.com.
The basic purpose behind the massage therapy is to alleviate pain and relieve one of tension, pressure etc. The process is can be simply explained, basically the relaxation of the muscles and tissues of the body increases the oxygen and blood delivery to those areas of the body where the massage is being performed, this results in a decreased level of pain suffered
02/23/10 @ 22:13
Comment from: Therapy4help [Visitor] · http://Therapy4help.com.
This is a very famous and renowned massage type. The massage is aimed at relaxing the joints and making them more flexible, this is done by giving long strokes to the person combined with muscle friction and kneading so that it flexes the joints.
02/24/10 @ 00:02
Comment from: Anna Karstens [Visitor] · http://unaico-sitetalk.net
Heya…my very first comment on your site. ,I have been reading your blog for a while and thought I would completely pop in and drop a friendly note. . It is great stuff indeed. I also wanted to ask..is there a way to subscribe to your site via email?
02/28/10 @ 11:05
You got great honest points here. I done a search on the issue and learnt most peoples will agree with your blog.
02/28/10 @ 11:56
its a desease...no nice way to put it...its a disease
03/01/10 @ 19:30
Comment from: San Diego short sales [Visitor] · http://www.theapprovalexperts.com
Hey, I think your really on track with this, I wouldn't say I am completely on the same page, but its not really that big of a deal .
03/04/10 @ 23:34
Comment from: Short sale in San Diego [Visitor] · http://www.theapprovalexperts.com
Just checking out your site on my new Garmin Phone , and I wanted to check if it would allow me reply or if it was going to me go to a desktop to do that. Ill check back later to see if it worked.
03/04/10 @ 23:39
Comment from: Topsoil Wilmington [Visitor] · http://www.landscapingwilmington.com/Topsoil.html
I will use your advice from now on. Jaap
03/06/10 @ 13:03
Comment from: dishwasher [Visitor] · http://www.stainlessdishwasher.org/
You had fantastic good ideas here. I did a search on the subject and discovered almost all peoples will agree with your blog.
03/07/10 @ 12:24
Comment from: Violet [Visitor] · http://www.heavymachinary.cn
I have been looking for content like this for a research project I am working. Thanks very much.
03/08/10 @ 07:56
Comment from: Fine Food [Visitor] · http://twitter.com/finestfoods123
thanks,
03/09/10 @ 09:37
Comment from: john panos [Member] Email
Hello Professor,

This may not be the proper category to address my question. What is your opinion on the hypothesis that drug addiction is a form of self-medication. Within this view the addicted individual may have chosen their particular drug to reach a state of positive affect to avoid a negative affect state. The individual may have originally been seeking a homeostatic balance for positive affect, but in turn after time the drug has changed the homeostatic set point thusly the individual now seeks the drug to maintain a homeostatic balance.

John
03/10/10 @ 11:09
Comment from: tabers cyclopedic medical dictionary - Ian [Visitor] · http://dictionary.chokyi.com/
Really nice post, Thanks! Just discovered this inspiring quote and want to share - "If you wait to do everything until you're sure it's right, you'll probably never do much of anything." Have a nice day!
03/10/10 @ 15:18

Leave a comment


Your email address will not be revealed on this site.

Your URL will be displayed.
:!: :?: :idea: :) :D :p B) ;) :> :roll: :oops: :| :-/ :( :'( |-| :>> :yes: ;D :P :)) 88| :. :no: XX( :lalala: :crazy: >:XX
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Name, email & website)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will not be revealed.)
March 2010
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
 << <   > >>
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31      

An open, unmoderated discussion forum for the Addiction Science Network, promoting free and open exchange of evidence-based information and promoting scientific analysis of drug addiction and related topics.

Search

Addiction Science Network

powered by b2evolution